A few years ago I went to a Judy Collins concert in NYC on Christmas Eve - Jim and my mom went with me. It was a great way to spend Christmas Eve. Carnegie Hall was comfortable, Judy Collins came on stage and her voice was beautiful. There were people around me of all ages. Toward the end of the concert we were all singing with her. About a year ago I told my friend, Carolyn, 'Yea - I sang with Judy Collins at Carnegie Hall, Jim didn't but I did." My friend's eyes almost popped out of her head, then I added "Of course she was on stage and I was in the audience". - Joan